The correct option is (c).
Explanation
Urban livelihoods are broadly categorized based on the nature of employment, security, and regulation. Street vending is a prominent part of the informal urban economy, characterized by self-employment and vulnerability, whereas permanent market shops typically operate within the formal or semi-formal sector with regulatory compliance.
Statement-wise Analysis:
- Statement 1 is Correct. Street vendors generally lack security of tenure and are often subject to eviction or relocation by authorities, although legislation like the Street Vendors Act, 2014, aims to address this. In contrast, market shop owners usually hold permanent municipal licenses and operate from fixed structures, granting them security of tenure.
- Statement 2 is Incorrect. Street vendors are typically self-employed or rely on family labour due to limited capital and small scale of operation. Permanent shop owners are more likely to employ workers and assistants. The assertion that street vendors "always" employ more workers is factually wrong.
- Statement 3 is Correct. Both groups are essential components of the urban economy, contributing to the distribution of goods and services. However, they operate with distinct differences in financial security, legal protection, and access to social security benefits.
Key Takeaway:
The primary distinction between street vendors and market shop owners lies in the security of tenure and the formalization of their business; vendors face high vulnerability in the informal sector, while shop owners enjoy regulatory protection and permanence.